Immigration reports tabled in Parliament 13 February 2008

The summaries below are to assist site users only. For a complete record of the reports and recommendations please refer to each report. Please note that all abbreviations used in the summaries are spelt out in full within the reports.

• Minister’s tabling statement—13 February 2008 (478.75KB)

• Immigration report 221/07 (252.46KB)

  Sri Lankan citizen aged 36 detained for two and a half years; Major Depressive Disorder, Somatization Disorder and narcissistic personality traits. Convicted of people smuggling. Review/Courts: AAT/RRT/FMC/FFC. Granted a RPBV.
  No recommendation by the Ombudsman.

• Immigration report 222/07 (208.55KB)

  PRC citizen aged 38 in detention for three years; with symptoms of PTSD and melancholic depression with suicidal ideation. Review/courts: RRT/FMC/MRT. Identity issues, PRC Consular visit May 2005.
  Ombudsman’s recommendation: That DIAC obtain an independent psychiatric assessment and take this advice into account in determining what detention arrangements or visa measures may be appropriate while removal processes are undertaken. That a decision be made on the s 417/48B application as soon as possible.

• Immigration report 223/07 (104.4KB)

  PRC citizen aged 55 in detention for two years. Depression; hospitalised with cellulitis in mid-2006. Review/Courts: MRT/RRT/FMC. For removal.
  No recommendation by the Ombudsman.

• Immigration report 224/07 (254.07KB)

  New Zealand citizen aged 31, resided in Australia for 21 years, in detention for two years; depression, anxiety and polysubstance dependence. Section 501 Review; best interests of a child. Review/Courts: AAT/FC. For removal.
  No recommendation by the Ombudsman.

• Immigration report 225/07 (254.07KB)

  Indian citizen aged 63 in detention for four years—with nine months concurrent criminal detention; symptoms consistent with Major Depression, auditory hallucinations. Review/courts: RRT/HC/FMC/MRT/FFC.
  No recommendation by the Ombudsman.

• Immigration report 226/07 (225.77KB)

  Foreign national aged 41 detained for two years; features of Major Depression. Alleged breach of privacy by DIAC. Assaulted in an IDC. Review/Courts: MRT/RRT/FMC/FFC. Released on BV.
  Ombudsman’s Recommendation: That consideration be given to ongoing case management and mental health support.

• Immigration report 227/07 (125.93KB)

  French citizen aged 47 resided in Australia for 38 years, detained for two years; personality disorder, diagnosed with schizophrenia in gaol. Criminal history and s 501 Review. Released from immigration detention due to Nystrom decision. Unlawful in the community, for removal when located.
  No recommendation by the Ombudsman

• Immigration report 228/07 (127.23KB)

  Combined third and fourth report, previous report # 57/06. Possibly North Korean citizen aged 40 detained for four years; headaches, insomnia, epigastric discomfort, anxiety and depression, psychosomatic symptoms. Identity not confirmed – NIVA, partner also in Australia. Released on a RPVB.
  Ombudsman’s recommendation: That consideration be given to granting a permanent visa to Ms X and her partner.

• Immigration report 229/07 (119.95KB)

  Combined fourth and fifth report, previous reports # 77/06 & 58/06. Possibly North Korean citizen aged 46 detained for five years. Identity not confirmed, partner also in Australia. Released on a RPVB.
  Ombudsman’s recommendation: That consideration be given to granting a permanent visa to Mr X and his partner.

• Immigration report 230/07 (309.18KB)

  Combined third, fourth and fifth report, previous report # 51/06. Foreign national aged 47, detained for five and a half years; PTSD, significant psychological distress. Serious character concerns, ICCPR & ITOA. Claim of assault by detention centre staff.
  Ombudsman’s Recommendation: That consideration be given to alternative detention arrangements while their case is resolved; if released, consider case management and support.

• Immigration report 231/07 (223.74KB)

  Tanzanian citizen aged 37 detained for three years; history of self-harm, Major Depression with psychotic features, elements of PTSD, involuntary psychiatric hospitalisation and guardianship order. Review/Courts: RRT/FC/FMC/FFC. Removed.
  No recommendation by the Ombudsman

• Immigration report 232/07 (251.85KB)

  Macedonian citizen aged 32 detained for three years; mental health issues & methadone program. Criminal history, s 501 Review. Review/Courts: RRT/FC/FFC. Released on THCV.
  Ombudsman’s Recommendation: That an independent psychiatric evaluation be sought if removal remains an option; DIAC consider case management & mental health community support.

• Immigration report 233/07 (285.91KB)

  PRC citizen aged 32 in detention for three years; unresolved identity issues; adjustment disorder, depression, anxiety; PRC Consular visit May 2005. Review/Courts: RRT/FMC/MRT/FFC.
  Ombudsman’s recommendation: That alternative detention arrangements or a suitable visa with work rights be considered.

• Immigration report 234/07 (221.84KB)

  Vietnamese citizen aged 34, in detention for two years; history of substance abuse. Section 501 Review, Australian-citizen partner and best interests of a child. Review/Courts: AAT/FC/FFC/RRT/FMC. Awaiting possible visa grant.
  No recommendation by the Ombudsman.

• Immigration report 235/07 (332.49KB)

  Indian citizen aged 29 in detention for two and a half years; victim of bullying and serious assault in an IDC; PTSD with depressed mood. Review/Courts: MRT/HC/FC/RRT/FFC.
  Ombudsman’s recommendation: That DIAC consider an alternative detention arrangement including community detention.

• Immigration report 236/07 (267.14KB)

  Afghan citizen aged 26 detained for two and a half years; escaped twice and unlawful in community for 27 months. Adjustment Disorder with symptoms of anxiety and depression. Maribyrnong to Baxter transfer, HREOC complaint. Australian-citizen wife and child. Review/Courts: RRT/FC. Granted a TPV.
  Ombudsman’s Recommendation: That DIAC offer a reasonable level of compensation for his treatment during the Maribyrnong to Baxter transfer.

• Immigration report 237/07 (193.34KB)

  Nepalese citizen aged 45 in detention for two and half years; with anxiety symptoms, irritability, insomnia and forgetfulness. Review/courts: Joined Macabenta class action/MRT/RRT/FMC/FFC.
  No recommendation by the Ombudsman.

• Immigration report 238/07 (172.32KB)

  PRC citizen aged 50 in detention for two and a half years; bone marrow disorder and mild depression. Review/Courts: FMC/FFC.
  No recommendation by the Ombudsman.

• Immigration report 239/07 (371.37KB)

  Sri Lankan citizen aged 45 detained for four years; Adjustment Disorder and Major Depressive Disorder. Mistakenly classified as an offshore entry person, Dulcot, Cocos (Keeling) Islands. Three-year FOI access delay. Australian-citizen fiancée. Review/courts: RRT/FMC/FC/FFC. Released on a RPBV and later granted a BLSV.
  Ombudsman’s recommendation: That DIAC provide Mr X with an explanation and apology for the FOI delay; factors to be taken into account for consideration of a permanent visa.

• Immigration report 240/07 (110.96KB)

  Fifth report, previous report # 136/07. PRC citizen aged 55 in detention for five years; chronic schizophrenia, refusing anti-psychotic medication, mild depression. For removal.
  Ombudsman’s recommendation: That DIAC maintain close and regular monitoring of the impact of removal plans upon Mr X; that if removal is delayed, alternative detention arrangements are considered—as per recommendation in previous report.

• Immigration report 241/07 (59.11KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 242/07 (62.24KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 243/07 (77.53KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 244/07 (77.53KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 245/07 (64.03KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 246/07 (61.13KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 247/07 (47.66KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 248/07 (43.76KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 249/07 (41.06KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 250/07 (43.59KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 251/07 (140.89KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 252/07 (136.92KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 253/07 (142.79KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 254/07 (140.78KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 255/07 (202.56KB)

  Afghan citizen aged 23 detained for four years; severe Major Depressive Disorder, PTSD, psychiatric hospitalisations, ongoing treatment for depression post-release. Review/Courts: RRT. Granted a GSHV.
  Ombudsman’s recommendation: That DIAC may wish to consider what role it needs to play in relation to the provision of ongoing care and assistance.

• Immigration report 256/07 (212.57KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 257/07 (227.96KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 258/07 (194.76KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 259/07 (161.73KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 260/07 (129.7KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 261/07 (143.52KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 262/07 (157.55KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 263/07 (233KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 264/07 (151.09KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 265/07 (182.17KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 266/07 (144.41KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 267/07 (888.8KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 268/07 (148.57KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 269/07 (197.79KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 270/07 (141.62KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 271/07 (166.25KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 272/07 (192.32KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 273/07 (202.51KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 274/07 (207.09KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 275/07 (192.19KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 276/07 (146.83KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 277/07 (467.7KB)

  Stateless man aged 33 detained for five years; born in Kuwait to Sudanese parents, not recognised as a citizen by Kuwait or Sudan, unsuccessfully applied for four third-country visas, removed in 2003 to Tanzania to seek travel documents for Sudan, not accepted as a Sudanese citizen and returned to Australia. Major Depression. Review/Courts: RRT/FMC/FC. Released on a RPBV.
  Ombudsman’s recommendation: That the Minister consider granting a permanent visa on compassionate grounds.

• Immigration report 278/07 (232.79KB)

  Second report, previous report # 207/07. Pakistani citizen aged 26 in detention for two and a half years; PTSD, anxiety and depression, methadone program. Review/Courts: FFC/HC.
  Ombudsman’s recommendation: That a suitable visa with work rights be considered.

• Immigration report 279/07 (212.03KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 280/07 (152.29KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 281/07 (48.83KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations

• Immigration report 282/07 (163.08KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 283/07 (178.58KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 284/07 (125.42KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 285/07 (140.76KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 286/07 (154.8KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 287/07 (168.87KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 288/07 (423.36KB)

  Sri Lankan citizen aged 37 detained for three years; with Panic Disorder with Generalised Anxiety, Major Depressive Disorder and PTSD; psychiatric hospitalisations, involuntary and voluntary. Entered Australia twice. Released on a BV. Review/courts: RRT/ Nancy Lie and Others class action /MRT/FC/FFC.
  Ombudsman’s recommendation: It will be necessary for DIAC to review the no work provisions of BV once Mr X’s health has stabilised. That Mr X not be returned to an immigration detention facility unless the medical opinion is that his mental health will not deteriorate as a result.

• Immigration report 289/07 (192.75KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 290/07 (213.53KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 291/07 (162.75KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 292/07 (178.77KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 293/07 (169.26KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 294/07 (214.32KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 295/07 (192.08KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 296/07 (150.69KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 297/07 (189.55KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 298/07 (234.87KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 299/07 (126.76KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 300/07 (180.82KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 301/07 (134.64KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 302/07 (192.09KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 303/07 (178.57KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 304/07 (203.96KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 305/07 (177.58KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 306/07 (176.77KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 307/07 (181.41KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 308/07 (167KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 309/07 (208.19KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 310/07 (181.36KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 311/07 (178.03KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 312/07 (150.76KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 313/07 (220.41KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 314/07 (149.26KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 315/07 (177.03KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 316/07 (189.56KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 317/07 (185.23KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 318/07 (146.78KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 319/07 (174.15KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 320/07 (197.26KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 321/07 (210.83KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 322/07 (162.24KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 323/07 (138.62KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 324/07 (193.37KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 325/07 (154.19KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 326/07 (169.24KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 327/07 (180.97KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 328/07 (193.88KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 329/07 (186.49KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 330/07 (203.64KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 331/07 (242.28KB)

  PRC citizen aged 54 in detention for two and a half years. Review/Courts: RRT/FMC. For removal.
  No recommendation by the Ombudsman.

• Immigration report 332/07 (216.57KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 333/07 (420.54KB)

  Combined third, fourth and fifth report, previous report # 63/06. PRC citizen aged 49 in detention for over five and a half years; adjustment disorder with depressed symptoms. Wanted in PRC for financial crimes, if for removal—ITOA to be pursued. Review/Courts: AAT/FC/FFC. In Alternative Detention.
  Ombudsman’s recommendation: That community detention, or a suitable visa with work rights, be considered. If a visa is granted, that DIAC consider providing case management to assist with the transition from immigration detention. The Minister may wish to consider a submission from Mr X, under s 501C, or by permission.

• Immigration report 334/07 (176.31KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 335/07 (243.83KB)

  PRC citizen aged 31 in detention for two and a half years; SASH. Review/Courts: RRT/MRT/FMC/FFC. For removal.
  No recommendation by the Ombudsman.

• Immigration report 336/07 (358.67KB)

  Combined third and fourth report, previous reports # 102/06 & 64/06. Male aged 48, has lost his Turkish citizenship, in detention for four years. Diagnosed with Chronic Delusional Disorder, he is appealing his guardianship order.
  Ombudsman’s Recommendation: That DIAC take steps to arrange his release from detention. That DIAC obtain a medical opinion on his prognosis and fitness to travel. The Minister may wish to consider exercise of his s 195A powers to grant a temporary or permanent visa.

• Immigration report 337/07 (234.72KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 338/07 (179.01KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 339/07 (222.96KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 340/07 (209.26KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 341/07 (187.16KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 342/07 (170.23KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 343/07 (155.65KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 344/07 (151.59KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 345/07 (159.02KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.

• Immigration report 346/07 (175.3KB)

  Abridged report. No recommendations.