The summaries below are to assist site users only, for a complete record of the reports and recommendations please refer to each report. Please note that all abbreviations used in the summaries are spelt out in full within the reports.
 |
|
|
62 year old citizen of Fiji in detention for two years. Degenerative knee condition. Review/Courts: MRT, FMC, FFC.
Ombudsman’s Recommendation: That the Minister expedite the decision on the current s 351 submission; that DIAC has further discussions with Mr X to assist him to understand his situation with probable removal if s 351 submission is unsuccessful. |
|
Second report, previous report # 70/06; 34 year old PRC citizen in detention for nearly three years; Falun Gong practice, PRC Consular visit and DIAC review. PTSD.
Ombudsman’s Recommendation: That the Minister expedite a decision on the s 48B request; if further delays in resolving immigration status, the Minister consider the grant of a BV with work rights. |
|
Combined second and third report, previous report # 26/06; 30 year old Vietnamese citizen in detention for over three years. Criminal history and s 501 visa cancellation. Generalised anxiety, ongoing detention impacting on mental health.
Ombudsman’s Recommendation: That the Minister uses her powers under 195A to grant a BV with work rights. |
|
16 year old citizen of Vietnam detained for two years. Review/Courts: RRT/FC. Successful at the RRT and released on a TPV.
Ombudsman’s Recommendation: In accordance with the ‘best interests of the child’ principle, the Minister give consideration to waiving the waiting period to allow an application for a PV. |
|
30 year old citizen of Iran detained for four and a half years. Difficulty in confirming nationality (claims to be from Iraq). Major Depression, PTSD. Review/Courts: RRT/FC/FFC/HC. Released on a RPBV.
Ombudsman’s Recommendation: That the Minister expedite a decision on the combined s 417/48B request; DIAC to consider what ongoing psychiatric assistance it should provide. |
|
48 year old citizen from the PRC in detention for two and a half years. Depressive illness and PTSD, assaulted at Villawood, PV sought under a false identity. Review/Courts: RRT/FMC/FFC/MRT.
Ombudsman’s Recommendation: That the Minister expedite a decision on the current s 417/48B request; if further delays in resolving immigration status, consideration be given to alternative detention arrangements due to current impact on mental health. |
|
44 year old PRC citizen detained for 2 years; anxiety and depression. Released on BV with no work rights or access to medical or financial support. Review/courts: RRT/FC/FFC.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: If removal delayed DIAC to undertake a review of his circumstances, including access to work rights. |
|
32 year old claiming to be a citizen of India detained for over 6 years; major depression, psychosis and suicidal ideation; repeated involuntary psychiatric hospitalisations. Identity and nationality issues. Length of detention concerns. Review/courts: RRT/FC Released on a RPBV.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: DIAC to consider providing ongoing medical and psychiatric support; the Minister to consider granting a permanent visa. |
|
21 year old citizen of the PRC in detention for two and a half years; Falun Gong practice; Review/courts: RRT/FMC
Ombudsman’s recommendation: Minister expedite s 417 submission. |
|
Third report, previous report # 47/06; 28 year old citizen of the PRC in detention for three and a half years; depression, voluntary psychiatric hospitalisation. PRC Consular visit and DIAC review.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: The Minister expedite the s 417 and s 48B requests, that he not be returned to an immigration detention facility, that a visa or alternative detention be considered, that there are a number of factors that may incline the Minister to grant a substantive visa. |
|
Combined second and third report, previous report # 29/06; 35 year old citizen of the PRC in detention for over 4 years; Falun Gong practice; PRC Consular visit and DIAC review; adjustment disorder and depression; lengthy delays in removal.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: Minister again consider granting a visa or consider alternative detention arrangements. |
|
37 year old citizen of Iran detained for 3 years, escaped for 3 years; major depression and PTSD.
Review/courts: RRT/FC/FFC/HC (discontinued). Granted a TPV.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: Minister consider waiving waiting period to allow an application for a PV. |
|
Combined second, third and fourth report, previous report 30/06; 54 year old Pakistani man detained for over three and a half years. Review/Courts: RRT/FMC/FFC. Released on a BVE.
Ombudsman recommendation: No recommendations made. |
