Commonwealth Ombudsman logo

Immigration reports tabled in Parliament 20 June 2006

The summaries below are to assist site users only, for a complete record of the reports and recommendations please refer to each report. Please note that all abbreviations used in the summaries are spelt out in full within the reports.
bullet

Minister's tabling statement - 20 June 2006

bullet

Immigration report 056/06

49 year old North Korean man in detention for three years. Nationality and identity issues, physical health problems. Review/courts: RRT/MRT.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: DIMA continue to resolve identity/nationality issues and process his PV application as a priority; that, pending resolution of his immigration status, a visa for release into community be considered.

bullet

Immigration report 057/06

39 year old North Korean woman in detention for two years; with physical health problems and concerns re use of paracetamol. Difficulty confirming nationality. Review/courts: RRT/MRT/FMC.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: That, pending resolution of her immigration status, a RPBV be considered (with reporting conditions); that a s 417 request is expedited.

bullet

Immigration report 058/06

45 year old North Korean man in detention for three years. Nationality & identity issues. Review/courts: RRT/MRT.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: DIMA continue to resolve identity/nationality issues; that, pending resolution of his immigration status, a visa for release into community be considered (with reporting conditions).

bullet

Immigration report 059/06

42 year old Turkish man in detention for two years; with depression. His wife is an Australian citizen and is hospitalised with a mental health condition. He lived in Australia for 18 years, escaped from detention on two occasions and was unlawful for six years. Drug offences and a s 501 cancellation. Review/courts: IRT/RRT/MRT/AAT/FC/FFC.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: That a s 417 request is expedited; if there is a delay, the grant of an appropriate visa (to enable release and reconnection with his wife) is considered.

bullet

Immigration report 060/06

49 year old Scottish born man, a permanent resident for 29 years; detained for two years. His criminal convictions led to s 501 visa cancellation. Minister granted RD due to man’s poor health. Released due to Nystrom decision, i.e. an ‘absorbed person’. Now deceased. Review/courts: FMC.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: None. Condolences to family.

bullet

Immigration report 061/06

35 year old Vietnamese man in detention for four years; with brain injury, depression, drug addiction and self-harm. A permanent resident for 20 years, his extended family and son are Australian citizens. Criminal convictions led to a s 501 visa cancellation. Review/courts: RRT/MRT/AAT/FMC/FC/FFC – judgement reserved.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: That s 417 requests are expedited; if there is a delay in the resolution of court and s 417 requests, consider release from detention on an appropriate visa.

bullet

Immigration report 062/06

46 year old Taiwanese man in detention for two years; with a possible serious mental illness. Now living in community with wife and five children on RD. Review/courts: RRT/FMC/FC.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: DIMA refer individual to mental health specialists; if removal attempted, DIMA to monitor impact on individual’s mental health.

bullet

Immigration report 063/06

48 year old PRC man in detention for four years; with Major Depression, anxiety and psychotic symptoms. Wanted in PRC for financial crimes, s 501 refusal. Review/courts: FC/FFC/HC/ an FC application is afoot.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: No specific recommendation. That alternative detention be considered. The Ombudsman considers that DIMA should seek assurances that person will not face the death penalty if he is removed.

bullet

Immigration report 064/06

46 year old Turkish man in detention two years; with a chronic Delusional Disorder and possible dental health needs. He has lost his Turkish citizenship and has a restricted capacity to make decisions about his immigration issues. Review/courts: MRT.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: For referral to an independent senior psychiatrist for assessment; for consideration of the most appropriate living arrangement; DIMA to approach Turkish Consulate to discuss waiving his military service obligations; dental surgery if necessary.

bullet

Immigration report 065/06

43 year old PRC man in detention five years (cumulative); with Major Depression. Identity problems and removal delays, PRC Consular visit. Review/courts: RSRC/RRT/MRT/FC.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: Expedite decision on Ministerial submission of December 2005, and that a RPBV be considered.

bullet

Immigration report 066/06

45 year old Indian man in detention two years; with chronic paranoid psychosis and psychiatric hospitalisation. Unlawful in Australia for 20 years, his family are now Australian citizens. Outstanding warrant for breach of AVO. Review/courts: MRT/FMC/FFC.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: The Ombudsman suggested that DIMA should canvass the option of a Residence Determination; that DIMA consult with police to resolve AVO warrant issues; that a s 351, and other submissions, are expedited.

[top]