Commonwealth Ombudsman logo

Immigration reports tabled in Parliament 7 February 2007

The summaries below are to assist site users only, for a complete record of the reports and recommendations please refer to each report. Please note that all abbreviations used in the summaries are spelt out in full within the reports.
bullet

Minister's tabling statement - 7 February 2007

bullet

Immigration report 105/06

38 year old citizen of Nepal detained for two years. Major depression, PTSD, self-harm risk, involuntary psychiatric hospitalisation; immigration detention a factor in the deterioration of his mental health. Review/Courts: RRT/FMC.
No recommendation by Ombudsman, however desirable that a permanent solution be soon found to his unresolved immigration issues and ongoing support needs to be considered by DIMA.

bullet

Immigration report 106/06

34 year old citizen of Iran detained for almost 5 years. Major depression, PTSD, several self-harm attempts and involuntary psychiatric hospitalisation. Guardian appointed. GSL used force in transfer to Red One. Apostate. Granted a TPV.
Review / courts: RRT/FC/FMC/FFC/HC.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: Amend policy to ban GSL officers using pressure points above the shoulder when using force as a last resort; Minister consider granting a permanent visa; appropriate for DIMA to consider ongoing medical and casework support.

bullet

Immigration report 107/06

36 year old married PRC woman and her 4 year old Australian born daughter, 2 children in PRC; detained for nearly five years. New PV claim arising from PRC delegation visit issues. Mother has PTSD, depression and anxiety; daughter has separation anxiety and disordered attachment to mother. Nutrition issues for daughter whilst in detention. Mother allegedly victim of sexual assault at VIDF.
Review / courts: RRT/FMC/FFC.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: That PV claim assessment be expedited; if PV claim unsuccessful consider humanitarian grounds and give weight to issues affecting daughter. Ombudsman not advised until after report completed that both were granted PV’s in September 2006.

bullet

Immigration report 108/06

37 year old man detained for almost six years. Previous report 40. Had a major depressive episode; delay in obtaining character clearance. Granted a TPV.
Review/courts: RRT/FMC/FFC/UNHRC.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: Minister consider granting a permanent visa, consider reintroducing into policy the requirement to notify legal representatives 48 hours prior to removal, DIMA to consider ongoing mental health support, post release.

bullet

Immigration report 109/06

29 year old PRC man in detention for over three and a half years. Falun Gong practice. Previous report 39. periods of anxiety and depression. Review/courts: RRT/FMC.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: That a combined s 417/ s 48B request be expedited; a RPBV be considered while his immigration status or his removal issues are resolved.

bullet

Immigration report 110/06

55 year old citizen of Indonesian detained for two and a half years. Wife subject of Report 111. Voluntary removal. Review/Courts: RRT/MRT/FMC/FC/FFC/HC
No Recommendation by Ombudsman

bullet

Immigration report 111/06

41 year old citizen of Indonesia detained for two and a half years. Husband subject of Report 110. Voluntary removal.
Review/Courts: RRT/MRT/FMC/FC/FFC/HC
No Recommendation by Ombudsman

bullet

Immigration report 112/06

38 year old ethnic Arab man detained for nearly five years. Severe PTSD, anxiety, major depression and self-harm. DIMA received new country information. Released on a RPBV and then granted a TPV.
Review / courts: RRT/FMC/FFC/HC.
Ombudsman’s recommendation: Minister to consider waiving the 30 month waiting period before he can be considered for a Permanent PV, DIMA to consider providing medical and casework support.

[top]